eBaybuy Listing Reader

Independent research on listing claims. No platform affiliation.

Polo Ralph Lauren Multicolor Shorts Collection Review: S, XXL and 5XL on the Same Table, Grading a Size Run Against a 1–2 cm Tolerance

We ordered S, XXL and 5XL of a $6.27 thin-polyester short and graded the flat measurements against the listing's 1–2 cm tolerance. The step between the middle and top sizes came up short.

Polo Ralph Lauren Multicolor Shorts Collection Review: S, XXL and 5XL on the Same Table, Grading a Size Run Against a 1–2 cm Tolerance
By Devon ParkReviews Editor Hands-on product testing, packaging inspection, fit checks, and delivery timing

Most reviews of a seven-colorway listing order the colors. We ordered the sizes. The Polo Ralph Lauren multicolor shorts collection (SKU 7720521196) runs from S to 5XL for $6.27 USD, marked down from $6.74 and listed as in stock, and a size run that wide is a bigger claim than any single 3D print. So our testing team bought three pairs — navy in S, orange in XXL, and white in 5XL — and put them on the same bench on the same afternoon.

Why two ends and a middle, rather than three colors

The listing says the shorts are available in S, M, L, XL, XXL, 3XL, 4XL and 5XL, with a stated 1–2 cm measurement tolerance. A tolerance is only useful if you know what it is applied to. By measuring the smallest, a middle and the largest size, we could see whether the run grades upward in even steps or whether the top end gets compressed — the failure mode that makes a 5XL fit like a generous 2XL.

The four measurements and how we took them

We laid each pair flat, unknotted the drawstring, and let the gathered waist settle for ten minutes before the first tape. Every pair got three passes of the same four numbers, recorded to the nearest half centimeter:

  • Waist, flat and relaxed, across the top edge
  • Outseam, from the top of the waistband to the hem
  • Inseam, from the crotch seam to the hem
  • Hem opening, measured straight across the finished leg opening

We then compared each number with the pair one size band below it, so the run could be read as a grade rather than three isolated garments. Packaging was photographed on arrival and the carton and polybag were both intact; checkout-to-door took 11 days.

What the tape said

SizeWaist flat (cm)Outseam (cm)Inseam (cm)Hem opening (cm)
S36.044.516.029.5
XXL43.051.518.533.5
5XL47.555.019.535.0

Where the size run compressed

From S to XXL, three size steps added 7.0 cm across the flat waist, 7.0 cm of outseam and 4.0 cm of hem opening — roughly 2.3 cm of waist per step, which is a normal, believable grade. From XXL to 5XL, another three steps added only 4.5 cm of waist, 3.5 cm of outseam and 1.5 cm of hem.

Put differently: the step from XXL to 3XL, and from 3XL to 4XL, and 4XL to 5XL, averaged about 1.5 cm of flat waist each — below the smaller end of the listing's own stated tolerance. Either the top of the run is graded tightly, or the pairs we received sit at opposite edges of that 1–2 cm band. We cannot separate those two explanations from three pairs, and we are not going to pretend we can.

The listing's stated 1–2 cm measurement tolerance is the same width as, or wider than, each individual step in the top half of the size run.

Fabric and print: thin, dry, and firm to the hand

The fabric is polyester, listed as thin with no stretch, and that is exactly what arrived — a light, slightly papery hand with no give when pulled across the leg. The waist is gathered on a drawstring, so the only stretch in the garment is at the top edge; the legs themselves do not move with you. For beach wear and hot afternoons that reads as a plus: the shorts stay off the skin and dry quickly on a line. For anything requiring structure or a heavier drape, it does not.

The 3D print on our three pairs sat cleanly, with no visible white gaps along seams or at the hem on the orange and navy pairs. The white 5XL was the one we watched, since white is where a print process usually shows thinness. It held; we noted no grey patchiness under indoor light. That is a comment on three colorways, not on all seven, so treat the other four as unverified until you have your own pair in hand.

The sizing question the listing does not answer

Ralph Lauren has several fit profiles, and buyer-shared guidance is consistent on one point: Classic-Fit runs about a size larger than typical domestic sizing, while Custom-Fit sits closer to Asian body sizing. Which profile this listing follows is not stated anywhere in the item specifics, and we could not confirm it from the page. Since the 5XL we measured is 47.5 cm across a relaxed flat waist, the answer matters at both ends of the run.

What brand-level reviews are and are not telling you here

Buyer feedback on the Ralph Lauren online store is poor — 1.6 out of 5 across 131 Trustpilot reviews, with recurring complaints about cheap fabrics, incorrect sizing and items arriving damaged. Those reviews concern ralphlauren.com, not this listing, and we do not transfer them onto a pair of shorts we measured ourselves. We include them because they describe a pattern of sizing inconsistency at the brand level, which is precisely why flat measurements, not the size letter, should drive your choice. A separate community review of Ralph Lauren replica polos found the material close to retail in hand and the branding convincing, which is mildly reassuring and no substitute for a tape measure.

What we would confirm before ordering a second pair

  • Ask the seller which fit profile the listing follows, and request flat waist and outseam for the exact size and colorway you want.
  • If you sit at the top of the run, ask for measurements of the specific size rather than assuming the grade is even — our XXL-to-5XL steps were the tightest.
  • Confirm the return terms before ordering multiple colorways, since the 1–2 cm tolerance is wide enough to cover a real fit difference.

On the things we could hold and measure — stitching at the hem, print registration on three colorways, the polybag and carton, and the four flat numbers repeated three times — the shorts did what a $6.27 summer short needs to do. The uncertainty sits in the sizing ladder and in the four colorways we never opened.

What works
  • Straight-hem polyester with a dry, non-clinging hand, matched to beach and summer use
  • 3D print sat cleanly on navy, orange and white, with no white gaps at seams
  • Wide S–5XL run; our pairs arrived intact with the 1–2 cm tolerance stated upfront
Watch-outs
  • Top of the size run grades tightly — about 1.5 cm of flat waist per step from XXL up
  • No stretch in the fabric itself; the only give is the gathered drawstring waist
  • Fit profile (Classic, Custom or Slim) is not stated anywhere in the listing
Who this is for
Buyers who want a cheap, light, straight-hem short for beach and hot weather, and who will send the seller for flat measurements before choosing a size.
Who should skip
Buyers who want stretch, a heavier or structured short, or who plan to order by size letter alone — especially at the top of the run.
Editor verdict
A light, quick-drying thin-polyester short that measured close to its stated tolerance at S and XXL, but the XXL-to-5XL steps ran narrow. Buy on flat measurements, not the size letter.

Frequently asked

Is the fabric stretchy?
No. The listing specifies thin polyester with no stretch, and our three pairs confirmed it — the legs have no give. Only the gathered drawstring waistband flexes, so do not size down expecting the fabric to relax.
What does the 1–2 cm measurement tolerance actually mean for sizing?
It means any single pair can differ from the listed numbers by up to 2 cm. Our XXL-to-5XL steps averaged about 1.5 cm of flat waist each, so the tolerance is as wide as a full size step at the top of the run.
Which Ralph Lauren fit profile is this?
The listing does not say. Brand-level guidance notes Classic-Fit runs roughly a size larger than typical domestic sizing and Custom-Fit sits closer to Asian sizing, so ask the seller which profile applies before ordering.

Sources and notes

  1. Catalog product page
    Product listing verified on 2026-10-30.

Community feedback 5

Reader score 3.8 / 5 (5 ratings)

J. Whitmore 3 / 5
Fair writeup but I wish there was a note on how the thin fabric held up after a wash. Measurements are one thing, shrinkage on cheap polyester is another.
hikingbetty 4 / 5
Good call checking the flat measurements rather than trusting the tag. Curious whether the S size ran true or was the odd one out, since smalls and big sizes often come off different lines.
sizecurve_sam 5 / 5
Grading a size run against a stated tolerance is exactly the kind of test more listings need. The middle-to-top step coming up short tells me more than any photo of a tape measure on one size.
Dan Okafor 3 / 5
$6.27 thin polyester for a Ralph Lauren label, feels like the label is doing all the work here. Still useful to see S, XXL and 5XL all measured on one table instead of guessing from stock photos.
thriftkeen_marta 4 / 5
The 1-2 cm tolerance breakdown is what I needed. I always eyeball flat measurements against size charts and get burned on the step between sizes. Did the XXL to 5XL gap end up smaller than spec, or just inconsistent?